2016 Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Comparison

2016 Honda Pilot
2016 Toyota Highlander

2016 Honda Pilot

Base Engine:

checkmark 3.5 L V6

Horsepower:

checkmark 280 hp @ 6000 rpm

Torque:

checkmark 262 ft-lbs. @ 4700 rpm

Fuel Economy:

checkmark 19/27 mpg*

Maximum cargo capacity:

checkmark 109.2 cu.ft.

2016 Toyota Highlander

Base Engine:

2.7 L Inline 4

Horsepower:

185 hp @ 5800 rpm

Torque

184 ft-lbs. @ 4200 rpm

Fuel Economy:

20/25 mpg*

Maximum cargo capacity:

83.7 cu.ft.

2016 Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander

Serving Clearwater, Tampa, Largo, St. Petersburg, Palm Harbor, FL

The 2016 Honda Pilot and the 2016 Toyota Highlander are two options that you must consider when you're in the market for an SUV with utility, functionality and fuel efficiency. Both vehicles are perfect for people who need a three-row SUV suitable for families or adventurers. They also offer exceptional resale value, and come equipped with a large number of convenience features.

The vehicles are part of a new line of crossovers that are designed to help you get more done and get where you need to go. Both vehicle offer superior cabin space, and there is enough room to take an entire large family with you. Alternatively, reduce the seats to make room for additional storage space. Both vehicles are ideal for anything from the weekend adventurer to a quick trip to the local supermarket.

Fuel Efficiency

Both the Pilot and the Highlander offer excellent fuel efficiency for an SUV. When you consider they have a comparable 3.5-liter engine, these two vehicles are pretty well fairly matched. The Honda Pilot edges out the Highlander when it comes to fuel efficiency by an estimated two miles per gallon on the highway. City driving will be comparable between the two vehicles, and both vehicles come standard with front-wheel drive or optional all-wheel drive. It really depends on if you need more horsepower or torque. The Pilot gives you slightly less horsepower, but the additional torque is going to be useful if you plan on towing.

Interior Improvements

The Pilot has been on the market a bit longer than the Highlander for the 2016 model season. Yet, the interior of the Pilot is drastically improved over previous versions. It has a modern and refined appearance that gives exceptional visibility. The Highlander is spacious as well, but it doesn't offer the same clear view of the road that the Pilot seems to command. The Pilot edges out the Highlander just slightly when it comes to interior options. Also, since it's been on the road longer, it's easy to see the reliability ratings. With the Pilot, you know you're getting a reliable vehicle. Based on past history, both vehicles should have good reliability ratings, but the Highlander is too new to know for certain.

The Best Value

Both vehicles seem to be priced comparably, but the Pilot is less expensive if you're looking to save some money and still get outstanding performance. You can opt for the less powerful version of the Highlander with a 2.7-liter engine option. However, the cost of the Pilot still works out to be about $3,000 less if you configure both vehicles with similar options and specs. When you consider that you can get just about everything with the Pilot that you can get with the Highlander, the Pilot is the better overall value.


Both vehicles offer outstanding performance and value, so you really can't go wrong with either choice. The best way to make a comparison for yourself is by scheduling a test drive. Contact your local Crown Honda dealership today.

* 19 city/27 highway/22 combined mpg rating for 2WD 6AT models. 18 city/26 highway/21 combined mpg rating for AWD 6AT models. 20 city/27 highway/23 combined mpg rating for 2WD 9AT models. 19 city/26 highway/22 combined mpg rating for AWD 9AT models. Based on 2016 EPA mileage ratings. Use for comparison purposes only. Your mileage will vary depending on how you drive and maintain your vehicle, driving conditions and other factors.